It's a regional thing. I think Flagstaff, AZ is one of the most outwardly dark-sky vigilant municipalities here on the mainland USA. I am actually a huge proponent of minimizing light pollution, and don't think I would be upset if moving forward we started designing lights to accommodate wildlife and skylight pollution. You also have the Big Island of Hawaii, which I have made a post or two on before, and their new approach by utilizing different color temp LED's to combat pollution. I think they are actually quite awesome, but everyone here likes to (...) on them.
As I remember Flagstaff from 15 years ago, it was to me really a LPS orange glow city.
But last year's visit was more of a mixture HPS/LED impression to me.
But I was visiting just the places surrounding the Interstate (I40, if I remember well).