Maybe so, but it was only turned on ONCE and had been on 24/7. It had not appeared to age (much) like the others, but it was black on one end and much dimmer this morning. The others I have HAD lasted a BIT longer, but not by much. They aren't very expensive so running tests for life might be fun. I tore the last one apart and it is VERY V E R Y bright in the microwave......