LED lanterns are out there for nearly a decade now, and i am yet to see the long promised one which light quality is better or at least comes anywhere close to that of HID
It would be nice lantern for HID but being LED it doesnt stand out from the lot of all other LED lanterns
I can tell LED and metal halide apart quite easily.
LED light is very cold. There is no warmth what so ever to it. Even though you cannot actually feel the heat of hid when it's far away I can certainly tell it's there. Even with cold looking light sources like uncoated mercury vapor.. I think it is maybe the infrared light that makes them nice
Personally speaking I think HID puts off a much more welcoming light even if it has low cri or weird colors.