When the further or higher the fixture is, or the higher the general illumination level is, the higher intensity gets acceptable. This has never changed. And installations using indirect lights are not "bare tubes" from this perspective (when the tubes are not in the direct view). But there were many installations like bare tube lights on a wall behind a bench at the eye level or so. There the bare tubes are too bright. But if you put them above, there is no problem. Of course people adopt to what became available: If low brightness tube ballast were available, placing two bare tubes directly on the wall became the easiest and cheapest thing, even when they are in the direct line of sight. When not (like for the T5's), a fixture with a single tube and a refractor to spread the light over larger area was chosen. The higher price and the need to clean it from time to time accepted as a fact of life, when there was no other choice. Or it was not installed on the wall, but onto some brackets or hung higher above the desk, so it was not at the eye level. Again a more complex and expensive setup, but if you have no other choice...
By the way in these applications this is the reason the T5's were in fact not more efficient than even T12: T8 or mainly T5 required a refractor, which absorbs a lot of light, so you need higher lumen light source to compensate for the losses. With a T12 tube, which could be run bare, the less losses means less lumens are sufficient, so even with the lower raw efficacy of the lamp the overall consumption becomes comparable.
LEDs can not work without a cover for electrical safety reason, but there is quite wide range of intensity to select from, so you use the lantern that suits the need. But the advantage of LEDs is, their lifetime allows to make the refractors sealed, so rather immune towards dirt accumulation on the rough side of the refractor (where the dust tend to stick and becomes difficult to clean out). Plus the LEDs do not expose the plastic to the UV, so there is wider selection of or less restriction to materials for it, so it could become cheaper.
|